Unraveling the Mysteries: Tankless Water Heater vs Tank – Pros and Cons

Understanding the World of Water Heaters: A Guide for Homeowners

Greeting homeowners, and welcome to our cozy corner of knowledge! Today, we’re tackling a topic that might make you go “meh” at first, but trust us, it’s as essential as they come. We’re talking water heaters, those unsung heroes humming away in the background, ensuring our showers are warm and our dishes are squeaky clean. So, let’s dive right into the deep end, shall we?

A Brief Overview of Water Heaters

For something we use every day, many of us know precious little about water heaters. These hardworking appliances are at the heart of any home, providing us with hot water at a moment’s notice. From a relaxing bath at the end of a long day to tackling that mountain of dishes after a family dinner, water heaters play an indispensable role in our daily routines.

While their working might seem akin to magic, it’s actually simple science. Water heaters, in essence, take in cold water from your supply pipe, heat it up using a variety of methods (which we’ll cover in a bit), and then deliver it to your faucets and appliances when you need it.

Necessity of Water Heaters in Modern Life

Now that we know a bit about what water heaters do, let’s ponder the obvious question: why are they so important? Well, we humans are creatures of comfort, aren’t we? A hot shower in the dead of winter, a warm wash for our dirty laundry, sanitizing our utensils with hot water – all these little luxuries we take for granted are courtesy of our dependable water heaters.

Apart from personal comfort, hot water also plays a key role in maintaining hygiene and cleanliness in our homes. Be it washing our hands, doing laundry, or cleaning dishes, hot water ensures that we are not just cleaning but also effectively killing germs and bacteria. In essence, water heaters contribute significantly to our comfort, cleanliness, and overall quality of life.

A Glance at Different Types of Water Heaters

Stepping into the world of water heaters can be a bit daunting, given the sheer variety of options available. Fear not, dear reader, we’re here to simplify it for you!

  • Storage Tank Water Heaters: 

These are your traditional, most commonly used water heaters. They store and heat water in a tank (thus the name!), and the hot water is available for use as and when required.

  • Tankless Water Heaters: 

As the name suggests, these models do away with the tank and heat water directly as it flows through the unit. These are also called on-demand water heaters, providing hot water exactly when you need it, thus potentially saving energy.

  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: 

These eco-friendly units don’t generate heat directly. Instead, they use electricity to move heat from the air or ground to heat your water. They can be more energy-efficient but might not work as efficiently in colder spaces.

  • Solar Water Heaters: 

Harnessing the power of the sun, these water heaters use solar panels installed on your roof to collect heat and transfer it to your water. They’re green, efficient, and can significantly reduce your energy bills, especially in sunnier climates.

  • Condensing Water Heaters: 

Ideal for homes with natural gas systems, these heaters utilize the exhaust gases that are typically vented out of the home, reusing the heat to warm up your water.

Understanding your water heater might not be as exciting as picking out a new sofa, but it’s just as crucial, if not more. From the daily comfort of hot showers to the necessities of a clean, germ-free home, water heaters are an essential part of modern life. Choosing the right one for your home, therefore, can make a significant difference in your comfort, energy bills, and environmental impact. 

Let us explore water heaters for your home, apartment or condo!

Repairing water heater. Young man working in uniform at construction at daytime
New tankless water heater installed in a garage.

Table of Content

  • Tankless Water Heaters – An Overview

  • Pros of Tankless Water Heaters

  • Cons of Tankless Water Heaters

  • Tank Water Heaters – An Overview

  • Pros of Tank Water Heaters

  • Cons of Tank Water Heaters

  • Tankless Water Heater vs Tank – Pros and Cons

  • Choosing the Right Water Heater for You

  • Tips for Maintaining Your Water Heater

  • Frequently Asked Questions

gas water heater replacement
Gas water heater replaced in a basement.

Demystifying Tankless Water Heaters: The What, How, and Types

Just when you thought you had a handle on the world of water heaters, we throw a curveball your way – the tankless water heater. An alien concept to some, an absolute game-changer to others, these nifty little machines are causing quite a stir in the market. Let’s explore why.

The Concept of Tankless Water Heaters

Tankless water heaters, as the name subtly hints, are water heaters sans the tank. Revolutionary, isn’t it? While traditional tank heaters work on the principle of storing a large volume of water and keeping it heated for use, tankless water heaters believe in the “live in the moment” philosophy. No storage, no standby, just on-demand hot water whenever you need it. The result? A much more efficient and convenient system that’s quickly becoming a favorite amongst modern homeowners.

How Tankless Water Heaters Work

It’s all well and good to claim efficiency and convenience, but how does it all work? The mechanics behind tankless water heaters are simple yet ingenious. When you turn on a hot water tap, cold water travels through a pipe into the unit, where either a gas burner or an electric element heats the water instantaneously. Hence, tankless water heaters deliver a constant supply of hot water, without the need for a storage tank to keep water hot.

One key thing to note, however, is that the output of a tankless water heater might limit the flow rate, meaning you might struggle to run multiple hot water appliances at the same time. But with a bit of planning and smart use, this little hiccup can be easily managed.

Various Types of Tankless Water Heaters

Now that we’re getting into the nitty-gritty, let’s look at the types of tankless water heaters available in the market:

  • Electric Tankless Water Heaters: 

Compact and easy to install, electric tankless heaters use an electric resistance coil to heat the water. They are ideal for smaller households and applications where the demand for hot water is relatively low.

  • Gas Tankless Water Heaters: 

As you might have guessed, these heaters use a gas burner to heat the water. They can heat more water per minute than their electric counterparts, making them suitable for larger households.

  • Propane Tankless Water Heaters: 

These heaters function similarly to gas heaters but use propane as their fuel source. They offer a great balance of power and energy efficiency.

  • Hybrid Tankless Water Heaters: 

Combining the best of both worlds, hybrid systems can operate as a tank or tankless unit as needed. They provide the flexibility of a large volume of ready hot water while still being able to function as an on-demand heater during periods of high usage.

Tankless water heaters, with their innovative design and efficient functioning, are an excellent choice for homeowners looking to save energy, space, and money. But wait, it’s not all sunshine and roses. Like any appliance, tankless water heaters have their pros and cons, which we’ll delve into in our next section.

Trending Now

Avoiding Common Mistakes: Wiring a Garbage Disposal Safely and Efficiently

Common Causes of Uneven Concrete Sidewalks and How to Fix Them

Transform Your Concrete Patio: 5 Easy Ways to Enhance its Appearance

Luxury Vinyl Plank Bathroom Flooring: Is It The Right Choice?

How to Choose the Right Patio Door for Your Home.

Common Roof Leaks: Where Does Your Roof Leak?

Where To Start When Designing A Bathroom

What is a Luxury Bathroom Renovations

How Do I Reset The Error Code On My Dishwasher

Maytag Dryer Control Board Replacement

How Often Should You Clean Your Dryer Vent?

What Is Considered An Emergency Appliance Repair?

Tankless Water Heaters – The Perks of Going Tankless

Choosing a water heater for your home is a lot like dating – you weigh the good against the not-so-good, and see if the balance tips in your favor. And like the perfect partner, tankless water heaters come with a pretty attractive list of perks. So, let’s play matchmaker and check out the pros of going tankless.

Energy Efficiency

If saving energy is high on your list of priorities (and let’s be honest, who doesn’t like lower utility bills?), tankless water heaters might just be your knight in shining armor. By heating water on demand rather than maintaining a tank full of hot water round the clock, these heaters can be up to 34% more energy-efficient for homes that use 41 gallons or less of hot water daily. Even for homes that use a lot of hot water – around 86 gallons per day – tankless heaters can still be 8-14% more energy-efficient.


A good water heater is an investment, and like any investment, you want it to last. Here’s where tankless water heaters earn their stripes. While traditional tank heaters generally last 10-15 years, a tankless unit can last up to 20 years, or even more if well-maintained. That’s almost like getting your kid through college!

Space Savings

In an era where minimalism is all the rage and every square foot counts, tankless water heaters score big with their compact size. Ditching the bulky tank means these units can be installed in smaller spaces, giving you more room for that home gym or office you’ve been dreaming about. Plus, many models can even be mounted on a wall, further reducing their footprint.

Continuous Supply of Hot Water

Imagine running a bath, only to find the hot water running out halfway through. Not fun, right? With a tankless water heater, you can say goodbye to such inconveniences. Since these heaters warm water as it flows through the unit, you get a continuous supply of hot water, no matter how long your shower karaoke sessions might be.

In a nutshell, tankless water heaters offer a host of benefits, from energy savings and longevity to space efficiency and endless hot water. Sounds like a dream, right? But remember, even dreams have their flip side. Keep reading in our next section as we delve into the cons of tankless water heaters.

Repairing a tankless water heater.
Repairing a tankless water heater.

Tankless Water Heaters – The Flip Side of the Coin

Alright, homeowners, we’ve sung praises about the benefits of tankless water heaters, but it’s time for a reality check. Like any other appliance (or anything in life, really), tankless water heaters come with their own set of drawbacks. Let’s shed some light on these so you can make an informed choice.

Initial Cost

When it comes to upfront costs, tankless water heaters can give your wallet a bit of a scare. These units tend to be significantly more expensive than traditional tank heaters. Plus, if you’re replacing a tank heater with a tankless one, you might need additional installation work, further increasing the initial expense.

Installation Complexity

Installing a tankless water heater is not exactly a Sunday DIY project. Depending on the type of unit you choose, you might need extensive electrical circuits, special venting, or larger gas lines. The installation process can be complicated and should be done by professionals to ensure safety and efficiency. This, again, can add to the upfront costs.

Limited Simultaneous Use

While tankless water heaters provide a continuous flow of hot water, they might struggle to keep up if you’re running several hot water appliances simultaneously. For instance, if you’re having a shower while the dishwasher and washing machine are also running, you might experience a drop in the water temperature or flow rate.

While tankless water heaters offer a range of benefits, they do come with a few disadvantages that might influence your decision. If you’re considering going tankless, it’s crucial to weigh these pros and cons against your specific needs and circumstances.

Now that we’ve got a handle on well, on demand water heaters, it’s time to shift our attention to their more traditional counterpart – the tank water heater. Buckle up and join us in our next section as we dive into the world of tank water heaters.

Tank Water Heaters – The Old Reliable

Time to step away from the new-age world of tankless water heaters and hop into our time machine. Destination? The era of traditional tank water heaters. These are the veterans of the water heater world, tried and tested over the years. Let’s get to know them a little better.

The Traditional Tank Water Heaters

Tank water heaters, often referred to as storage tank water heaters, are the most common type found in homes today. They consist of a large tank (typically holding 20 to 80 gallons of water) that stores and heats water. A pretty straightforward and simple design, but one that’s stood the test of time.

How Tank Water Heaters Work

The mechanism of a tank water heater is as uncomplicated as its design. The heater fills the tank with water, and an element (either electric or gas) heats the water. The heated water remains in the tank until you turn on a hot water tap. As you use the hot water, the tank refills and reheats a new batch.

One crucial feature of tank heaters is the thermostat, which regulates the temperature of the water stored in the tank. It prevents the water from becoming too hot and causing potential safety risks.

Various Types of Tank Water Heaters

Tank water heaters come in a variety of shapes and sizes, and different types are better suited to different applications:

  • Gas Water Heaters: 

These heaters use a gas burner to heat the water and typically have a higher recovery rate than electric models, meaning they can heat more water faster.

  • Electric Water Heaters: 

These heaters use electric resistance coils to heat the water. They’re generally less expensive to purchase and install than gas models but can cost more to operate due to higher electricity prices.

  • Heat Pump Water Heaters: 

Also known as hybrid water heaters, these models use electricity to move heat from the air or ground to heat the water, making them much more energy-efficient than traditional electric heaters.

  • Solar Water Heaters: 

These use the power of the sun to heat water, offering the potential for significant energy savings. They can be a bit pricier upfront but can pay off in the long run, especially in sunny climates.

Having familiarized ourselves with the workings of tank water heaters, it’s time to delve into their pros. Join us in our next section as we discuss the advantages of sticking with the traditional route.

Tank Water Heaters – The Advantages of Sticking to Tradition

There’s a reason traditional tank water heaters have stood the test of time. They offer a number of advantages that continue to make them a popular choice among homeowners. Let’s take a look at the reasons why tank water heaters might still be your cup of tea.

Lower Upfront Costs

When you’re watching your pennies, a tank water heater could be a more economical choice. These units typically have a lower purchase price than tankless models. Plus, the installation costs are generally more affordable too, since replacing a tank heater with a new one usually doesn’t require significant modifications to your home’s infrastructure.

Simple Installation

Remember the nightmare we talked about with installing tankless water heaters? Well, you can breathe easy with tank water heaters. The installation process is straightforward, typically involving fewer complications and requiring less time. This means you can get your hot water up and running sooner, without the need for extensive (and expensive) professional assistance.

Simultaneous Multiple Usage

Finally, here’s one area where traditional tank water heaters pull ahead of the pack. These heaters store a large amount of hot water that’s ready for use, meaning you can run several hot water appliances simultaneously without affecting the temperature or flow rate. So go ahead, run that dishwasher while you luxuriate in a hot bath!

In a nutshell, tank water heaters offer advantages that are hard to ignore. They’re a reliable, cost-effective option, especially for households with moderate hot water needs. But remember, every rose has its thorns. Stay tuned for our next section, where we’ll shed some light on the cons of tank water heaters.

electric and gas tanked water heater.

Tank Water Heaters – The Hitches in Tradition

While tank water heaters hold their ground firmly in many respects, they aren’t without their own set of drawbacks. To give you a well-rounded view, let’s pull back the curtain on some of the less appealing aspects of traditional tank water heaters.

Energy Consumption

Let’s face it, tank water heaters aren’t exactly poster children for energy efficiency. Why, you ask? Well, they maintain a full tank of hot water 24/7, leading to what’s known as “standby heat loss”. This means they’re constantly using energy to keep the water hot, even when you’re not using any. If reducing your carbon footprint (and utility bill) is high on your priority list, this might be a bit of a turn-off.

Size and Space Requirements

While tankless water heaters are compact and space-saving, traditional tank heaters are quite the opposite. They require a fair amount of space due to the size of the tank, which might be a stumbling block if you’re working with limited room. If your home’s like a well-played game of Tetris, fitting in a large tank heater might be a challenge.

Limited Supply of Hot Water

Tank water heaters come with a fixed amount of hot water in their tank. Once it’s depleted, you’ll need to wait for the tank to refill and the water to heat up again. So if you’ve got a big family, or if your hot water demand often peaks simultaneously (say, everyone getting ready in the morning), you might occasionally find yourself facing a cold shower.

Like anything else, traditional tank water heaters come with their set of pros and cons. It’s all about what fits best with your lifestyle, budget, and hot water needs. Coming up next, we’re going to explore some FAQs about tankless water heaters vs tank heaters, so stick around!

Modern tankless water heater mounted on a home wall, symbolizing energy efficiency.
Tankless on demand water heater.
traditional water heater.
Traditional tanked hot water heater.

Tankless Water Heater vs Tank – The Showdown

We’ve spent a fair amount of time going over the specifics of both tankless water heaters and traditional tank water heaters. Now, it’s time for the face-off. We’ll put these two contenders side by side and see how they stack up in terms of energy efficiency, longevity, space requirement, and hot water supply. Let’s get ready to rumble!

Comparison of Energy Efficiency

In terms of energy efficiency, tankless water heaters generally have the upper hand. They heat water only when you need it, eliminating the standby energy loss associated with keeping a tank of hot water on standby 24/7. However, it’s also important to remember that the energy savings may be offset by the higher upfront cost of tankless units.

On the other hand, traditional tank water heaters, while less energy-efficient, have lower upfront costs. If you’re operating on a tight budget, a tank heater might still be a viable option, despite its higher operational costs.

Comparison of Longevity

When it comes to longevity, tankless water heaters generally win the race. They typically last longer than traditional tank water heaters, with life expectancies of around 20 years compared to 10-15 years for tank heaters. This longer lifespan might offset the higher upfront cost over time.

Comparison of Space Requirement

Space is another area where tankless water heaters shine. These units are compact and can be installed on a wall, freeing up valuable floor space. On the other hand, traditional tank water heaters, due to their size, require more space. If space is a premium in your home, going tankless might be a sensible choice.

Comparison of Hot Water Supply

As for hot water supply, it’s a bit of a mixed bag. Tankless water heaters provide an endless supply of hot water, but they might struggle if you’re running several hot water appliances simultaneously.

In contrast, tank water heaters can supply multiple appliances at once, thanks to their reserve of hot water. But once that tank runs dry, you’ll have to wait for it to refill and reheat, which could mean cold showers if the hot water demand is high.

Phew! That was quite a showdown. Hopefully, it has provided some valuable insights to help guide your decision-making process. But the choice between a tankless water heater and a tank water heater is not a one-size-fits-all solution. It depends on various factors such as your budget, space availability, hot water needs, and energy-saving goals. As we move to the next section, we’ll discuss how to choose the right water heater for you.

Choosing the Right Water Heater for You – A Personalized Approach

Now that we’ve got all the information on the table, it’s time to apply it to your specific situation. Choosing between a tankless and a tank water heater will depend on your unique needs, financial considerations, and space availability. So let’s break it down!

Analyzing Your Needs

First off, how much hot water do you actually need? If you live alone or have a small family, a tankless water heater could be a great fit. They’re ideal for people who use less water and can avoid running multiple hot water appliances simultaneously. However, if you have a large family or often need a lot of hot water at once (say, running the dishwasher, washing machine, and shower at the same time), a tank heater could be more up your alley.

Financial Considerations

Next up is budget. Tankless water heaters have a higher upfront cost than tank heaters. However, they can save you money in the long run due to their energy efficiency and longer lifespan. If you’re willing to make the initial investment, you may see cost benefits down the road. On the flip side, if your budget is tight, a tank water heater’s lower upfront cost may be more appealing.

Available Space

Space is another critical consideration. If you’re short on space, the compact size of a tankless water heater could be a game changer. But if you’ve got plenty of room to spare, the bulkier tank water heater won’t be much of an issue.

Remember, the choice between a tankless and a tank water heater is personal and depends on several factors. Do your homework, consider your individual circumstances, and make the choice that best suits your needs and lifestyle.

Once you’ve made your decision and your new water heater is humming away, it’s important to keep it in tip-top shape. How, you ask? Well, that brings us to our next section: Tips for maintaining your water heater.

water heater repair
Inspecting the water heater components.

Tips for Maintaining Your Water Heater – A Healthy Heater is a Happy Heater

Whether you’ve opted for a traditional tank heater or a sleek, modern tankless unit, your water heater will serve you best with a little TLC. Here are a few maintenance tips to keep your water heater performing at its peak and prolong its lifespan.

Regular Inspection

Just like you’d take your car for regular tune-ups, your water heater also benefits from routine inspections. This helps catch any small issues before they turn into significant problems. Look out for signs of leaks, corrosion, or other abnormalities. And while you’re at it, check the pressure relief valve to ensure it’s functioning correctly. This simple step could save you from a lot of potential hassle down the line.

Flushing the System

Over time, sediment can build up in your water heater, reducing its efficiency and leading to potential damage. To avoid this, it’s recommended to flush your tank water heater annually. For tankless units, consult your manufacturer’s instructions – they may require professional servicing less frequently, say every few years.

Temperature Settings

Monitoring and adjusting your water heater’s temperature can enhance its efficiency and safety. The Department of Energy recommends a setting of 120 degrees Fahrenheit for optimal performance. However, if you have a high hot water demand or if your dishwasher lacks a booster heater, a slightly higher setting might be necessary.

Maintaining your water heater not only ensures a steady supply of hot water but also extends the life of the unit and can help save on energy costs. Remember, a well-cared-for water heater is a long-lasting one!

Now that we’ve equipped you with the knowledge to choose and maintain your water heater, let’s move on to the FAQs section. We’ve compiled a list of common questions about tankless water heaters and tank heaters to further help you navigate your water heating journey.

Frequently Asked Questions – Your Queries Answered

Ah, the FAQ section, a haven for all those burning questions. Here, we’ve gathered and answered some of the most common questions about tankless and tank water heaters. So, without further ado, let’s dive in!

Tankless water heaters tend to have a longer lifespan than their tank counterparts. On average, a tankless water heater can last around 20 years, while a tank water heater usually lasts between 10-15 years. However, this can vary depending on factors such as usage, water quality, and how well you maintain the unit.

The cost to install a water heater can vary significantly depending on your location, the specific model, and whether modifications to your home are needed. That said, tankless water heaters generally cost more to install than traditional tank heaters. While a tank water heater might set you back a few hundred dollars for installation, a tankless unit could cost you over a thousand dollars. However, remember that the long-term energy savings and lifespan of a tankless water heater may offset the higher upfront costs.

Tankless water heaters can be more energy-efficient than tank heaters because they only heat water on demand, eliminating the standby energy loss associated with tank heaters. You could potentially save up to 30% on your water heating bill with a tankless unit. However, the exact savings will depend on your water usage patterns.

While tankless water heaters provide an endless supply of hot water, they might struggle with simultaneous demand from multiple appliances. If you often use a lot of hot water at once, like running the shower and dishwasher simultaneously, you might need a larger tankless unit or even multiple units to meet the demand.

Yes, due to the complexity of installation, it’s recommended to have a professional install your tankless water heater. The process might involve modifying your plumbing system, venting system, or even electrical wiring, which should always be handled by a professional to ensure safe and efficient operation.

We hope these answers help you in your water heating journey! Whether you choose a tank or a tankless water heater, we’re sure you’ll make a decision that suits your needs perfectly

Conclusion – The Final Takeaway

And there you have it! We’ve taken a deep dive into the world of water heaters, comparing and contrasting tankless and tank water heaters, and helping you navigate the often-overlooked but essential domain of home heating.

To sum it all up, both tankless and tank water heaters have their unique strengths and weaknesses. A tankless water heater could be your go-to if you value energy efficiency, long-term savings, and don’t have a high simultaneous demand for hot water. On the other hand, a tank water heater might be right up your alley if you prefer lower upfront costs, simple installation, and need to run multiple hot water appliances at the same time.

Remember, the choice isn’t about which type of heater is objectively better, but rather, which is better for you. So, take your time, consider your specific needs, space, and budget, and make the choice that fits your lifestyle best.

We hope this guide helps you feel confident in your decision and that you’re now equipped to choose the right water heater for your home. Here’s too many warm showers, clean dishes, and cozy spaces!

Additional Resources – Further Reading and Information

There’s a wealth of information out there to help you delve deeper into the topic of water heaters. Here are ten resources that offer valuable insights and further information:

From understanding the intricacies of water heater technology to tips on maintenance and upkeep, these resources cover a broad spectrum of topics.

Atlantic City
Corbin City
Egg Harbor Township
Estell Manor

Galloway Township
Hamilton Township
Hammonton Township
Margate City

Port Republic
Somers Point
Ventnor City

Get a FREE Plumbing Quote

Leave a Reply